Miami Is Giving Citizens a Bitcoin Dividend

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day

Nov. 11, 2021

If you were forwarded this newsletter and would like to receive it, sign up here.

Sponsored by

Welcome to The Node.

Questions? Feedback? We'd love to hear from you! Simply reply to this email.

–Daniel Kuhn

Today's must-reads

Top Shelf

BLUE SKIES AHEAD: Twitter is launching a dedicated cryptocurrency team led by former Tendermint developer Tess Rinearson. The social giant has already integrated BTC Lightning tips, plans to integrate NFT functionality and is working on a decentralized social protocol called Blue Sky. "Looking farther ahead, we'll be exploring how ideas from crypto communities can help us push the boundaries of what's possible with identity, community, ownership and more," Rinearson said.

BTC DIVIDEND: The City of Miami will soon give out a "bitcoin yield" to its citizens, Miami Mayor Francis Suarez announced on CoinDesk TV Thursday morning. The yield comes from the staking of the city's own cryptocurrency, Miamicoin, which was introduced early this year and has already earned over $21 million in the past three months for Miami, or one-fifth of Miami's total annual tax revenue of $400 million (at an annualized level).

DAO DOWN: The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) stopped a Wyoming-based decentralized autonomous organization (DAO) from registering two digital tokens as securities, the agency said on Wednesday. The SEC alleged American CryptoFed "filed a materially deficient and misleading registration" that omitted information and mischaracterized its ducat and locke were utility tokens.

LONG WAY TO GO? A Morgan Stanley analyst found that firms that have embraced the metaverse – Facebook, Roblox and Naver – have already benefited (or at least their stocks have). The research note states the metaverse exists but not in its "purest form," which would be a fully interoperable digital rival to reality. Meanwhile Sotheby's, the legacy auction house that has moved hard into NFTs, will accept ETH for live bidding at a coming show in Decentraland. Finally, research from Art Tactic found that 77% of NFT art sales over the past 21 months went to male artists.

ODDS & ENDS: FTX US's daily trading volume soared 512% in Q3. Canadian crypto miner Hut 8′s revenue rose over 700% in Q3, beating analyst estimates. Agoric, a Cosmos-based smart contract platform, launched its public chain a month after closing a $32 million private token sale. Acala, a DeFi platform on Polkadot, has brought in $608 million worth of DOT tokens during a voting procedure to determine who gets to "lease" a parachain slot on the blockchain.

A message from Nexo

When it comes to buying, borrowing or earning on your crypto, you won't find and easier, safer way to do it than Nexo.

Right now you can earn $25 worth of Bitcoin for each friend you refer. And the best part is that your referral gets $25 in BTC too!

How it works? It's quite simple – sign in to your Nexo account, copy your unique link and start referring like your life depended on it!

And here's what'll happen next: you and your referrals will both get $25 in BTC within 30 days of them passing Advanced Verification and topping up the equivalent of $100 or more of any asset supported on the Nexo platform.

There's no limit on the number of people you can refer, so invite as many friends as you'd like!

Join Nexo and start earning free BTC with your friends!

Overheard on CoinDesk TV ...

Sound Bites

"I do see very quickly a world where the Satoshi system is what is used to make payment."

–Miami Mayor Francis Suarez, on CoinDesk TV's "First Mover."

What others are writing...

Off-Chain Signals

Rolling Stone Mints First-Ever NFTs With Bored Ape Yacht Club (Decrypt)
Amid regulatory woes, Binance CEO details France HQ ambitions (The Block)
Bitwise Withdraws Application for Bitcoin Futures ETF (Blockworks)
Curve Turns Off Mochi's Rewards After 'Amazingly Scammy' Tactics Trigger Outcry (The Defiant)
Chris Dixon and Packy McCormick on the future of crypto (The Economist – paywalled)
Big one on Binance (WSJ)

A message from Amber

Amber Group is an integrated digital asset platform serving retail and institutional clients by providing deep liquidity, attractive yields, and sophisticated portfolio management tools. With 12 offices on three continents, and nearly a trillion dollars in volume traded, Amber Group offers clients personalized, compliant, and secure service across dozens of digital assets.

Find out more at https://www.ambergroup.io/

CoinDesk's "Most Influential" recognizes individuals who've had a big impact on the cryptocurrency and blockchain industry in a calendar year. Chosen by readers and editorial staff, the list features 50 people from across the space, including entrepreneurs, traders, coders, regulators, celebrities and the odd surprise. To have your say on who should make this year's list, check out the form here. The results will be announced on Dec. 6, 2021.

Putting the news in perspective

The Takeaway

'Probably Nothing': Why People Still Hate Crypto

Daniel Kuhn, reporting in. It ended pretty much the same way it began, with a tweet. Discord founder and CEO Jason Citron yesterday went to reassure users that the popular messaging platform will not be integrating crypto after all. This comes after a period of public backlash, where users threatened to or shared screenshots of deactivating their paid Nitro memberships, over the possibility that Discord would lean into crypto.

Earlier this week, over Twitter, Citron seemed to suggest that someone at Discord was working on Ethereum functionality. A screenshot showed MetaMask and WalletConnect, a tool used by many mobile crypto wallets, among the possible integrations alongside existing YouTube, Reddit and Facebook widgets.

"Probably nothing," Citron said, the ironic phrase used by crypto enthusiasts to say something is a big deal. Indeed, it would be something. People read into the comment that Discord might soon add native tooling useful for non-fungible tokens (NFTs) and decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs). Already the chosen home for many Web 3 projects, it seemed like Discord was joining the decentralized legion.

But not everyone was pleased with this potential new direction – a move that would reflect changing consumer behavior and perhaps a value shift at the gaming-focused company. It's a useful reminder that even as crypto surges, becoming a darling of venture capitalists and a significant cultural and economic field, there's still a significant amount of people that just don't like what the industry stands for.

Slacktivists responded to Citron's tweet calling for others to ditch the platform and cancel their paid subscriptions, one of the main revenue streams for a company that has resisted advertising. Many regurgitated claims of Ethereum's intense energy use and noted how crypto scams have proliferated on the platform. Others just noted how annoying "NFT bros" can be.

Discord listened. Citron said Wednesday evening the platform has "no current plans" to integrate crypto wallets into its app. Indeed, this was never a formal announcement, and the tooling was likely part of a hackathon.

"We're excited about the potential for Web 3 technology and the positive ways these communities are coming together on Discord, especially those organized around environmentally friendly, creator-focused projects," the company told TechCrunch. "However, we also recognize there are some problems we need to work through. For now, we're focused on protecting users from spams, scams and fraud."

Web 3, the generic term for a blockchain-based alternative to the internet where users can own their data and hold stake in the tools they use, is a positive development. Outside of legal challenges to monopolistic internet giants, crypto presents the best way to counteract "surveillance capitalism."

But for those that haven't drunk the Kool-Aid, crypto appears to be hyper-capitalistic, capitalism-plus. It prefers markets over the state to find solutions and protect everyday people. It's an avenue for the already rich to make almost insultingly large amounts of money. It advances the "neoliberal turn" towards financialization, globalization and commodification of everything.

Even though crypto promises a lot – in a phrase, "digital sovereignty" – it hasn't achieved much over its decade-long existence. (Discounting the $3 trillion market cap.) That was a point repeatedly made last month, when Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) supporters took umbrage that the nonprofit focused on digital rights took a stand against overregulation of crypto.

The EFF shared over Twitter an op-ed written by heads of Fight For The Future and the Blockchain Association, two technology lobbying groups, that argued for crypto users to "confront" the "existential threat" of regulation. People were miffed – again, primarily, over environmental concerns and rampant scams. Some vowed to never again financially support the EFF.

These are people who conceivably might support crypto from a digital rights and privacy perspective. But like the angry Discord mob, they seem to have already made up their minds about the industry. In both cases, these are likely savvy internet users and are not dismissing crypto out of hand.

There are legitimate reasons to be suspicious of crypto. Its current privacy issues (everything stays on a blockchain) and carbon footprint are solvable. It'll be harder to reconcile crypto's capitalistic aims – call it what you want, say Bitcoin is for all, but the money doesn't lie – at a time when more people than ever are skeptical of the economic status quo.

Does crypto subvert the system or play into it? Is the discord it creates adding value? For now, as far most people are concerned, it's "probably nothing."

–Daniel Kuhn

Sponsored Content

NEAR Predictions: Developers Chart the Bridge to Professional Freedom

Today developers operating in Web 3.0 are actively leveraging decentralized infrastructure to create products they want to build, whether it's green non-fungible tokens (NFTs), social networks where users own the data or groundbreaking new technology like sharding. Developers alone have unique tools and access to communities to create such novel products away from traditional corporate structures.

They also have the freedom to choose what networks and what tools to use. At NEAR, we believe the future is multi-chain, not "one blockchain to rule them all," which is why we've spent the past 12 months building bridges between networks. A developer on Ethereum, for example, can take advantage of NEAR's speed, security and scalability without having to write any more code.