Bitcoin: Gold 2.0? Try Reserve Asset 3.0

Insights, news and analysis for the professional investor

March 13, 2022

Supported by

Bitcoin (BTC) - $38,498.61

Ether (ETH) - $2,540.25

Prices as of 3/13/22 @ 1:00 p.m. UTC

Was this newsletter forwarded to you? Sign up here.

Welcome to Crypto Long & Short.

Last week I included a link to an Odd Lots podcast episode with Zoltan Pozsar, a respected interest rate strategist at Credit Suisse, in the Podcasts Worth Listening To part of the newsletter. I hadn't read much of his work (really I had read none of his work), but last Monday he published a note that mentioned Bitcoin. Naturally, I had to dive in.

For this week's newsletter, I wanted to break down this technical (and slightly unapproachable) piece Pozsar published and provide enough context so that you can get something out of it without slogging through things about "June FRA-OIS spreads widening" or G-SIBs. The piece is worth reading, but maybe this is more appropriate for a Sunday read.

That (and maybe more) below...

– George Kaloudis, research analyst

Buy bitcoin and 100+ cryptocurrencies with 20+ fiat currencies. New users can enjoy 0% credit/debit card fees on all crypto purchases made in their first 30 days. Download the Crypto.com App now.

The Briefing

On Monday, some people (like me) were struck by a brief note published by Zoltan Pozsar, Credit Suisse's short-term interest rate strategist, about a new world monetary order. At first blush, the full note (available here) seems to be unrelated to Bitcoin (but more on that later).

Pozsar sees the "birth of Bretton Woods III – a new world (monetary) order centered around commodity-based currencies in the East that will likely weaken the eurodollar system and also contribute to inflationary forces in the West." Here's what it might mean for us if his assessment of the world is accurate and how it's related to Bitcoin.

I totally already know, but what is Bretton Woods again?

The Bretton Woods system was a system of monetary management established in 1944 as World War II was ending. It set the rules for financial relations between countries and created the International Monetary Fund, World Bank and World Trade Organization. In short, Bretton Woods outlined the rules central banks and governments played by financially.

Entire books have been written about Bretton Woods, and so I won't pretend this newsletter is an exhaustive history of how things happened, but it helps to recall (as painlessly as we can) how we got from Bretton Woods I to III.

First, we need to explain one important concept. The term "countries' reserves" is thrown around a lot with little explanation. It simply means that governments hold different types of currencies, securities or commodities (i.e. "stuff") to react to things that are happening in the economy. For example, if your currency looks weak, you sell foreign currency and buy your own. Without "stuff" in reserve, governments and central banks can't react. Countries are free to hold whatever "stuff" they want in reserve.

The first iteration of Bretton Woods, now called Bretton Woods I, was a gold-based system where the U.S. dollar dominated and was freely convertible into gold at $35 per ounce (about 5,600% below its current price). This is where "the U.S. dollar is backed by gold" misappropriation comes from. In 1971, a confluence of factors led to the U.S. changing its currency so that the dollar was free-floating and backed by the full faith and credit of the government, not to mention by a massive military and oil.

From there, Bretton Woods II was born, where the dollar still dominates, but in a system that mostly uses "inside money." Inside money is made up of claims that are someone else's liability, while outside money is the type of money that is the liability of no one. In other words, the money system became largely debt-based. So when China holds U.S. Treasurys, that is inside money. When Russia sells USD to buy gold, that is outside money.

The regime we have lived in for a while now can cause a whole lot of confusion. Is it necessarily bad for Americans that China holds their debt and owes China a lot of money? Maybe, but maybe not since the U.S. has control over it (Treasurys are inside money, after all).

It also makes the inner workings of international finance annoyingly complicated. Fierce economic rivals fight (dirty, sometimes) for dominance in whatever industry, while also relying on each other for economic robustness. Proof of that is China holding $1.1 trillion of Treasurys in its own reserve. On one hand, we can't live with each other, and on the other hand, we would be dead without each other.

So is bitcoin the ultimate outside money or something else?

Given the war in Ukraine, the world took action and seized a large portion of Russia's reserves. As Castle Island Venture's Nic Carter put it, U.S. President Biden "dropped a financial nuke on Russia." An important designation was made by excluding energy-related payments, given Europe's dependence on Russian oil and natural gas. It's important because prices for commodities like oil and wheat have been skyrocketing. Thus, China is in a fortuitous position to strengthen its currency in the face of a commodity crisis.

Russia is one of the world's largest commodities exporters and, because of the sanctions, Russian commodities are less desirable than commodities from other countries. The People's Bank of China, which has massive amounts of now seizable, U.S.-based inside money, could defensively sell Treasurys to fund the purchase of "subprime" Russian commodities. In addition to giving China control over inflation, such action could lead to commodity shortages and a recession in the West.

This shouldn't be taken lightly. Although Russia has sold U.S. dollar assets for gold (and other stuff, see chart below) the past few years, the foundation of Bretton Woods II has splintered.

Tack on Russia's partial banning from SWIFT – a messaging system that supports international bank transactions – to the new confiscation risk associated with U.S. inside money and we could be looking at the beginning of a new monetary regime, a "Bretton Woods III." Now, we are facing a world where there may be a sharper focus on outside money, like gold and other commodities as countries boost their reserves.

Or they may turn to bitcoin.

This point is exactly the impetus for writing about this topic for the newsletter. To end his note, Pozsar wrote:

After this war is over, "money" will never be the same again…

…and Bitcoin (if it still exists then) will probably benefit from all this.

While not exactly a signal of bitcoin support, I would still call that a mic drop.

Off-exchange settlement in a trustless trading environment means unleashing maximum capital efficiency and more aggressive investment strategies.

ClearLoop brings Copper's custody and leading digital asset exchanges into one secure trading loop where funds are delegated, not moved. Balances are immediately available for trading and settlement is instant, with capital ready to be redeployed in milliseconds.

ClearLoop is the institutional investor's unfair advantage, offering greater control during high volatility while mitigating counterparty risk.

Book your demo today.

Takeaways

The consumer price index continued to rise as U.S. inflation hit another four-decade high. TAKEAWAY: Food and shelter played a large role in pushing inflation even higher during February, and the near-term outlook is expected to worsen. With war breaking out between Russia and Ukraine, oil prices and the general cost of living look to continue rising in the West. While Bitcoin showed strength when inflation expectations were on the rise in 2021, it appears generally uncorrelated at the moment.

President Joe Biden issued a much-anticipated executive order focused on crypto Wednesday morning, giving the market temporary relief. TAKEAWAY: The announcement and release of the executive order both appeared to have profound effects on the crypto market, with bitcoin slumping to $37,387 leading up to the release and then jumping 10% nearly immediately when the order was leaked Tuesday night.

Ethereum layer 2 infrastructure provider Starkware plans to raise around $100 million at a $6 billion valuation. TAKEAWAY: Starkware plays a critical role in building zero knowledge (zk) rollup technology, a critical piece in Ethereum's scaling plans. The company has built StarkNet and StarkEx and is known for hosting popular applications, such as perpetuals exchange dYdX. The funding round is expected to triple Starkware's valuation last seen in a round three months ago.

Bain Capital announced a crypto division to run alongside the $155 billion private equity giant. TAKEAWAY: Bain Capital Crypto launched a $560 million fund, with Bain Capital being the largest limited partner. Managing Partner Stefan Cohen highlighted that crypto is much different from traditional venture capital and that the team will add value by "advising on key economics, interacting with on-chain governance, providing liquidity and staking."

Crypto enthusiast Yoon Suk Yeol won South Korea's presidential election on Wednesday. TAKEAWAY: The president-elect has promised to deregulate the crypto industry in South Korea to help realize the "unlimited potential of the virtual asset market." South Korea was once known in crypto for the "Kimchi Premium," crypto assets trading at a significant premium to their market value due to the country's capital controls – which potentially signals both measurable interest in the sector and overbearing regulation.

– Teddy Oosterbaan, research analyst

Podcasts Worth Listening To

The Breakdown, With NLW

A Watershed Moment: Everything You Need to Know About Biden's Crypto Executive Order

Lots of studies, no onerous rulemaking.

Conversations with Tyler

Sam Bankman-Fried on Arbitrage and Altruism

Coordinators are that which is scarce.

New Money

Playing to Win: How Gamers Are Using Crypto and Where the Market Is Going

Popular competitive gaming experts Denver Moore, known as "That Denver Guy," and Cole Rodey from The Rodey Bros join forces to discuss the lifestyle, hustle and future of gaming.